Highlights
- South Africa’s current telecom laws require that telecommunications providers have at least 30% Black ownership as part of its post-apartheid BEE policy
- The BEE policy is central to empowering previously disadvantaged South Africans
- However, there is a plan to provide an alternative to Black ownership rules that will pave the way for Elon Musk’s Starlink to operate in Africa’s biggest economy
A fierce debate is shaping the future of satellite internet in South Africa. Proposed changes to Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) regulations could pave the way for global players like Elon Musk’s Starlink to enter the market, promising game-changing connectivity for millions. But at what cost? Below, we break down the controversy, what’s at stake, and where things may go from here.
What’s Behind the Starlink and BEE Debate?
Reliable, affordable internet remains out of reach for millions of South Africans, especially in rural regions. Starlink, the rapidly expanding satellite internet project founded by Elon Musk, offers a new hope with its low-Earth orbit satellite network, it can deliver fast broadband almost anywhere.
However, South Africa’s current telecom laws require that telecommunications providers have at least 30% Black ownership as part of its post-apartheid BEE policy. This regulation is central to empowering previously disadvantaged South Africans. Yet, it also presents a significant hurdle for foreign companies wishing to set up shop in the country without ceding major shares of their businesses.
Recently, Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi proposed a controversial workaround. Instead of strict Black ownership, companies like Starlink could meet requirements through an “equity equivalent” scheme, allowing for alternative investments in empowerment initiatives. The debate is now raging in Parliament and across the country.
Breaking Down the Proposed Regulatory Changes
The Core Proposal
- Amend BEE rules to allow non-ownership-based alternatives (“equity equivalent schemes”) for foreign entrants like Starlink.
- This approach is meant to address gaps in regulations that currently block big international telecom players from entering the vibrant, yet highly regulated, South African market.
- The changes would not eliminate the current ownership requirement, but create a parallel option for compliance.
Political and Legal Pushback
- Some lawmakers and major parties, including the ANC (African National Congress), are vocally opposed, arguing this opens a “back door” to foreign firms at the expense of local empowerment.
- Others demand legal clarity, questioning whether such a regulatory shift requires a full legislative amendment or falls under the minister’s authority.
- Requests for legal opinions have been tabled to determine alignment with the Electronic Communications Act and overall telecom policy.
International and Diplomatic Context
- The directive came shortly after President Cyril Ramaphosa met with US President Donald Trump in Washington, partly to repair strained relations.
- Elon Musk, a South African-born US tech titan, attended the Oval Office meeting, adding further intrigue and high-profile attention to the local policy debate.
Why Starlink Matters for South Africans
The Digital Divide
According to a 2023 national survey, just 1.7% of rural households in South Africa have reliable internet access. Traditional broadband and mobile data remain patchy and expensive in remote areas, reinforcing inequality and limiting digital opportunity.
The Starlink Promise
Starlink’s technology holds potential to:
- Deliver fast, reliable internet to underserved and remote areas.
- Bypass the challenges of laying cable and building cell towers in vast rural regions.
- Support education, healthcare, business growth, and digital inclusion.
If allowed, Starlink could fundamentally reshape the internet service landscape, making high-speed access more widely available at lower cost.
The Local Market Impact
Major operators like MTN are watching closely, with MTN already trialing satellite partnerships (including Starlink) in other African markets where rules permit. South African consumers, especially those outside big cities, could benefit enormously from new options and robust competition.
Challenges and Concerns Around Opening the Market
The Equity Dilemma
South Africa’s history of economic exclusion makes BEE a vital policy for social and economic transformation. The “equity equivalent” proposal has critics concerned it will dilute hard-won gains by letting large international companies bypass core ownership requirements.
National vs. Global Interests
Critics argue that revising rules for international tech giants risks favoring foreign business interests over boosting local entrepreneurs and historically disadvantaged communities.
“We are not going to accept a situation where our laws are going to be rewritten in Washington,” said Sixolisa Gcilishe of the Economic Freedom Fighters. The ANC’s Tshehofatso Chauke echoed that concern, emphasizing the priority should remain on empowering South Africans.
Legal and Legislative Questions
- There is ongoing debate over whether the proposed rule change can be implemented under current law or if it requires a formal amendment approved by Parliament.
- Legal experts are being consulted to advise on compliance with existing Electronic Communications Act provisions.
The Road Ahead for Satellite Internet in South Africa
The current proposal is now open for public comment, with operators like MTN reviewing details and expected to provide feedback within a 30-day window. A decision is likely to come only after robust debate, legal input, and political negotiation.
If the changes go ahead, South Africa could see:
- A boom in rural connectivity, bringing more communities into the digital fold.
- New market dynamics, with global players competing alongside local telecoms.
- Broader questions about the future of BEE and the balance between local empowerment and global competitiveness.
Alternatively, if Parliament resists, foreign satellite services could remain largely out of reach for most South Africans, leaving the digital divide in place.
What Should South Africans Watch For Next?
- Public comment outcomes as citizens, businesses, and lobby groups voice support or opposition to the proposed regulatory changes.
- Legal opinions that clarify whether changes require Parliament’s approval or can be enacted by ministerial directive alone.
- Potential revisions to the proposal in response to public and political feedback.
- Actions by operators like MTN, Vodacom, and others as they position themselves for whatever regulatory landscape emerges.
Shaping a Connected Future
South Africa stands at a crossroads. The decision around Starlink and BEE rules will ripple far beyond telecom policy, touching issues of equity, opportunity, and national identity. It’s a chance for robust public debate on how best to deliver digital inclusion, foster meaningful economic empowerment, and keep pace with a rapidly evolving global tech landscape.
South Africans should stay informed, speak up during the comment period, and demand solutions that deliver both fair access and genuine transformation. The way forward will require a careful balancing of opportunity, local interest, and historical responsibility.
Follow Money Finance ZAR’s extensive finance and business news updates on WhatsApp here.
